Wednesday, July 22, 2015

George Van Dyke - Gilded Age New England Lumber Baron


After the end of the Civil War, the United States went on a growth and building spree that demanded huge amounts of lumber. In the west, this lumber came from the upper northwest corner of the country, from Oregon and Washington. In the east, it was shipped down the Connecticut River from Maine and the Connecticut Lakes region, in huge shipments of logs managed by log drivers, who “rode the logs” down the river, risking life and limb to make sure the logs kept moving, breaking up any log jams that occurred along the way. David Sumner, the river’s first log baron, had made a fortune moving logs downriver. He died in 1867, and his enterprises were small compared to the huge companies that dominated the lumber trade during the Gilded Age.

In David Sumner’s time, logs were floated all the way down the Connecticut River from the headwaters near the Canadian border to the mouth of the river into the Atlantic in Old Saybrook, Connecticut. By the late 1800’s, people in Springfield, Massachusetts and Hartford, Connecticut had more leisure time and more money. They enjoyed using the river for recreational boating, forcing lumber companies to process their logs further upriver. As a result, several lumber companies combined resources and started lumber mills in Holyoke and at Mount Tom in Northampton. In a logical sequence of events, these companies merged and became the Connecticut River Lumber Company in 1879.

The Connecticut River Lumber Company was the biggest lumber company that had been seen on the river. David Sumner’s goal in business was to support his family, and he managed to do that in very well, even building a mansion that stands to this day. Sumner’s fortune and his “mansion” were small potatoes compared to the fortunes that the CRL Co amassed in the late 1800’s. Business owners in the Guilded Age weren’t called “robber barons” for nothing. They let nothing stand in their way, and George Scott and Thomas Pearsall of CRL were no exception.

CRL was not, however, the only company driving logs on the river. The Turners Falls Lumber Company and the McIndoe Falls Lumber Company also floated their stock down the Connecticut. The season was too short for log drivers and their bosses to sit around and wait for other log companies to clear the water. When CRL tried to drive out their competition, they found the owner of the McIndoes Falls Company to be extremely stubborn and difficult. In a prime example of cutthroat competition, the story is that George Scott told one of his managers to “go back up there and kill him off”. Apparently the McIndoe Falls guy was too tough even to kill, so the next best thing was to hire him. In 1884, CRL’s general manager retired due to failing eyesight, and the company hired George Van Dyke to replace him.

George Van Dyke was born in 1846, in a log cabin in Quebec. He was the fifth of eight children. His family was poor, and he started working in a lumber camp in Maine at age 14 and by age 19 was managing a crew on the river. Although he did not have much formal education, George had a sharp business mind, a strong will, and a drive to make money fueled by his impoverished childhood. These attributes, with practical experience working with lumber and the powerful physical strength acquired through years of arduous labor, combined to produce the most powerful and aggressive timber baron in New England history.

By 1870, George was working for himself, and bought several sawmills along the Connecticut River. Through business deals and hard work, and probably some underhandedness as well, he began amassing a fortune. Bill Gove, in his book “Log Drives on the Connecticut River” describes one of George’s first business deals. “In 1879, Van Dyke found himself unexpectedly in temporary possession of another sawmill on the river. He made a $100 purchase of a timber lot in Hereford, Quebec and parlayed that into a cut of about a million feet of logs. (Translation: The adjoining landowners probably had some of their logs removed also.)” One gets the impression that this was typical of George Van Dyke, ruthless and not above a little extra-legal maneuvering, especially if he could get away with it.

It seems that things always worked that way for George Van Dyke during that decade. He took that million feet of logs and drove them to a sawmill in South Lancaster, New Hampshire, just as the mill went bankrupt and none of the sawmill crew would work. As the bank took ownership of the mill, George commandeered his own crew of drivers to operate the sawmill and cut up his logs. All this just when lumber prices had skyrocketed, leaving George with a profit of $10,000 when everything was said and done.

In 1877, he and his partner Henry Merrill took over the sawmill at McIndoe Falls when that mill’s former owners went bankrupt. It wasn’t long before George bought out Henry’s part of the business and became sole owner. A few years after becoming general manager of the Connecticut River Lumber Company, he bought a part ownership of the company and became company president. In 1897, George paid George Scott and Pearsall $1.5 milllion dollars and became sole owner of the company.

As the years went by, George recognized that it would be easier to cart supplies and equipment up and down the river by railroad rather than by water. Established railroad lines did not want to expand to the North Country, fearing there wouldn’t be enough business. Undaunted, George built the Upper Coos Railroad and the Upper Coos and Hereford Railroad, which extended all the way to Sherbrooke, Quebec. Although he still shipped his logs down the Connecticut River, he did build some railroad spurs east and west of the river, to access even more timber.

Windsor County Court May 5


Jonathan Miller, DOB 5/25/83, pleaded not guilty to a charge of his second DUI, in Windsor on April 11, and also peaded not guilty to a charge of driving with a suspended license in Windsor on April 14.

Samuel Chase, DOB 8/1/87, pleaded not guilty to a charge of his first DUI, in Hartland on April 14

Simon Mauk, DOB 10/20/95, pleaded not guilty to a charge of possession of LSD in Hartford on March 8. You can read more about these charges here: http://www.masslive.com/news/index.ssf/2015/03/massachusetts_teen_arrested_in.html

Craig Twombley, DOB 6/6/69, pleaded not guilty to a charge of his first DUI, in Bethel on April 15

Chad Slack, DOB 6/25/72, pleaded guilty to a charge of simple assault in Royalton on January 27

Christian Cowell, DOB 9/6/97, pleaded not guilty to a charge of heroin possession in Springfield on March 12. In March, Cowell had also pleaded not guilty to 3 charges of promoting sexual recording in Springfield.

Tyler Garrant, DOB 3/17/94, pleaded not guilty to a charge of his first DUI, in Bethel on April 19

Shannon Wetherington, DOB 3/17/94, pleaded guilty to a charge of her first DUI, in Windsor on April 19

Megan Hennessey, DOB 4/18/90, pleaded guilty to a charge of her first DUI, in Royalton on April 17.

Joshua Congdon, DOB 10/5/79, pleaded guilty to a charge of driving with a suspended license, on March 2 in Springfield.

Windsor County Crime Online:






Gregory Smith, age 30, of Springfield, pdf of affadavit concerning fatal shooting: http://blackpearl.wcax.com/documents/GregorySmith201504B.pdf








Sunday, July 12, 2015

Guilded Age Log Drives Down the Connecticut River


David Sumner, lumber baron of Hartland, Vermont, died in 1867 at age 97. Sumner had owned large tracts of land near the Connecticut Lakes, and hired crews of men to cut logs off his land in the north country and float them down the Connecticut River to Hartland. In Hartland, many of the logs were cut into lumber, loaded onto rafts, and floated downstream to Holyoke and Chicopee, Massachusetts, or Hartford, Connecticut. Some were diverted away from the shallow rapids through a canal and lock system and sent whole down river to be sawn into lumber somewhere further south. As impressive as Sumner's log drives were, the huge log drives that have become so famous in the history of the Upper Valley occurred after Sumner's death.

David Sumner died in 1867, at the end of the Civil War and at the very beginning of the Gilded Age, when cities and towns across America grew at a feverish pace. The economy was booming and lumber from Northern New England was in huge demand as new buildings sprung up everywhere. Everything was happening on a huge scale, and that included the log drives down the Connecticut River.

Although railroads had arrived in Maine, Vermont and New Hampshire, they did not reach into northern timber forests, but the streams and rivers did. When transportation methods for most goods produced in northern New England switched to the railroads, logs continued to be floated down the river. Most of the small lumber mills along the way went out of business, and the logs were driven downriver in gigantic drives all the way from the Canadian border to Southern Massachusetts and Connecticut.

In 1869, O.F. Richardson of Bangor, Maine was hired to head a log drive of 1.7 million board feet of logs from the Canadian border to Holyoke. In his book “Log Drives on the Connecticut River”, author Bill Gove describes that first huge log run. “Richardson looked to some seasoned rivermen of Maine to handle the task, and he brought 36 seasoned veterans down with him, including one man who was 56 years old.” These men had honed their trade on the Penobscot River in Maine, and were unfamiliar with the Connecticut River. They had a fair amount of trouble that first year, when logs would get caught up in the eddies below the dams and rapids and they had to work all night to pick them out and send them on their way. Gove says that the men “would form a single file into the river, hold hands for steadiness and security, and the man at the far end, the “post of honor” had the dangerous job of pushing individual logs back into the river. (This is where the phrase “log jam” comes from, when someone refers to a log jam of paperwork or a log jam of traffic.)

They were quick learners, though, and in a few years crews from Maine moved larger and larger payloads of logs down the Connecticut River. In 1873, a crew of 150 men drove 26 million board feet of lumber from the Connecticut Lakes to Holyoke. The first recorded fatalities occurred the next year, when two men drowned near White River Junction while trying to cross from one log jam to another. The River is particularly dangerous around White River and Hartland, where currents are strong, eddies are common, and the river is not always predictable. The many bridges across the river in the Upper Valley created even more hazards, as logs tended to jam up around their stone supporting piers. Rivers in New England are most dangerous in the Spring when water is high due to spring thaw runoff, not only because the current is super fast but also because the water is freezing cold. Log drives had to take place in the Spring because as the water level receded during the dry summer, the level of water in the river would not be sufficient to float all those logs.

After the Civil War, the only places that still had significant amounts of timber available for logging were in the northwest and northeast corner of the country. In the northeast, lumber and logging companies drove more and more logs downriver every year to feed the building frenzy as America grew during the Guilded Age. The log drivers devised new methods to drive more logs faster, and break log jams more quickly. In typical Guilded Age fashion, these new practices were good for the companies but even more dangerous for the workers. Logs were gathered behind booms, lengths of chain stretched across the river, under the theory that logs jams that were built by loggers would be more manageable than those created by the random forces of the river. Log drivers used dynamite to blow up log jams. Bill Gove describes the time a jam on the ledges at Bellows Falls was broken when a men was let down by rope between two bridges and picked the key logs out of the jam, then yanked back up as the jam broke beneath him.

Robert Pike, writing for The Atlantic Online, describes log driving as a profession that was dangerous to life and limb, not just some of the time, but every minute.

“The heavy, slippery logs that he had to roll, pry and lift would fly back at him
and knock him literally to kingdom come, or he himself would slip and a
whole rollway would pass over him, leaving not enough to bury. On the
Penobscot, rivermen buried their dead comrades where they found them,
hanging their spiked boots on tree branches over their graves. At Mulliken's
Pitch, at the foot of the Fifteen-Mile Falls on the Connecticut, they used to
bury rivermen in empty pork barrels. When the New England Power Company
built to great dam precisely at the Pitch in 1930, it excavated half a dozen of
those makeshift coffins, the old spiked boots still intact.”

Milliken's Pitch was said to be the most dangerous place in the whole river. Also called the Fifteen Mile Falls, this spot was located in Monroe, New Hampshire at the very northern boundary of Grafton County. It was destroyed when the dam was built.

There weren't many riverdrivers from the Upper Valley, and by this time, the log bosses and lumber company owners were from the north country as well. The log drives came right through the Upper Valley every year, though, and the vast majority of dangerous spots were between Barnet, Vermont and Bellows Falls. Crews would sometimes have to wait for days on end for log jams to break up, taking the opportunity to visit saloons, restaurants and sometimes brothels in the river towns.


Thursday, July 2, 2015

Windsor County Court, April 28


Rebecca Dunbar, DOB 6/4/77, pleaded guilty to a charge of disorderly conduct on March 8 in Hartford.


Kenneth Carter, DOB 12/4/65, pleaded not guilty to a charge of heroin possession on March 30 in Hartford.

Erica Brown, DOB 9/2/80, pleaded not guilty to a charge of her first DUI, in Rochester on April 11.

Daniel Ricker, DOB 7/19/69, pleaded not guilty to a charge of his first DUI, in Sharon, on April 8

Matthew Henderson, DOB 1/30/87, pleaded not guilty to a charge of burglary of an unoccupied building in Hartford

Matthew Martin, DOB 7/26/84, pleaded not guilty to a charge of possession of narcotics in Springfield on March 13. Martin was also charged with violating conditions of release, specifically a 9 PM to 6 AM curfew. He pleaded not guilty to a charge of grand larceny in January. Read more about these crimes here: http://www.rutlandherald.com/article/20150312/NEWS02/703129883

Rourke Harte, DOB 6/2/78, pleaded not guilty to a charge of driving with a suspended license in Ludlow on March 21.

Michael Divincenzo, DOB 3/14/70, pleaded not guilty to charges of DUI and disorderly conduct, in Royalton on March 18.


Randall Rupp, DOB 8/29/75, pleaded not guilty to a charge of his first DUI, in Windsor on April 4



The following individuals pleaded not guilty to charges of driving with a suspended license:

James Dickinson, DOB 2/19/78, in Bethel on March 28

Anthony Brasile, DOB 10/26/63, in Sharon on March 1

Jessie Cormier, DOB 5/6/83 in Windsor on March 24



Thomas Emerson, DOB 8/13/59, pleaded guilty to a charge of driving with a suspended license, in Ludlow on March 9

Matthew Rudy, DOB 10/13/82, was charged with his second DUI, and ttwo counts of cruelty to a child, in Sharon, on April 6. Read more about these charges here: http://www.ourherald.com/news/2015-04-09/Communities/Driving_Drunk_With_Two_Kids_In_the_Car.html

Joshua Vanhise, DOB 2/28/92, pleaded not guilty to a charge of violating conditions of release, specifically addressing buying, having, or drinking alcoholic beverages, in Windsor on March 24



Windsor County Crime Online:












David Sumner, Hartland's 19th Century Lumber Baron


David Sumner was Northern New England's first lumber baron. He started out as a storekeeper in Hartland. He inherited some woodland, then bought some more woodland and went into the lumber business. In 1805, he married Martha Foxcroft, the daughter of a doctor from Brookfield, Massachusetts. Soon after, he built a mansion in Hartland, that is still there as a bed and breakfast inn.

Martha, nicknamed Mattie, never had any children and died in 1824. David remarried Wealthy Thomas, from Windsor, in 1838.

The trees that were cut on Sumner's land in northern New Hampshire by the Connecticut Lakes was floated down the river to Hartland. At Hartland, it was either shipped south to be cut into boards in Holyoke, Massachusetts or Hartford Connecticut, or cut into boards at his lumber mill on the Connecticut River at Sumners Falls. In “Log Drives on the Connecticut River”, author Bill Gove says that the majority of the homes built in Hartford, Connecticut in the early 1800's were built out of Sumner's lumber.

David contracted most of his log drive labor, hiring other men to get the logs down the river. This meant that he avoided having to be responsible for crews of men that had to travel from the Canadian border to the mouth of the Connecticut River. Gove mentions several different contractors who drove logs downriver for David. It seems like he hired a different contractor every year. He did, however, have some business agents who made sure everything was going according to plan and the company wasn't getting ripped off.

Lemuel Gilson and Charles Johnson were contractors for David Sumner. Lemuel and his wife Wealthy had 5 children. I thought it was weird that both Lemuel and David Sumner had wives named Wealthy, but I tried and tried to find a connection and did not find one. Lemuel was born in Hartland and died there at age 60. He had three daughters and two sons and at least four of them lived to be grownups. Charles Johnson lived in Newbury and had one son who moved to Worcester, Massachusetts. Johnson lived to be 77 years old and died in Beloit, Wisconsin. These men worked for David, but they also did other logging work, and Charles Johson and his brother Cyrus appear to have been quite well off.

David hired several agents to travel along the river to locate and retrieve pirated logs. Valuable logs floating freely down the river were tempting to anyone who lived along the river and was hard up for cash. Albion Taylor, John Kimball, Luther Rogers, and Albert Hunter were agents Gove mentions in the book, but I cannot find any futher information on any of them. David had a business manager named Nathaniel Page. It seems that David did not have much personal contact with the contractors and agents he hired, although Nathaniel kept close tabs on them. David and Nathaniel Page had a close personal relationship, and in 1821, they joined with some other prominent citizens of Hartland in petitioning the Vermont legislature for the establishment of a secondary school in Hartland, the Hartland Academy. Although the Hartland Academy never came into existence, the two men's signatures side by side on the application shows that they worked together as more or less equals, on endeavors other than David's businesses.

Over the years in which David Sumner was the lumber king of the Connecticut River, there were hundreds and hundreds of nameless workers, mostly from the Connecticut Lakes region and northern Vermont and New Hampshire, who traveled through the Upper Valley, literally on the river, moving lumber. These men were paid low wages to risk their lives driving logs from the Canadian border, through David's lumber mill and canal and locks at Sumners Falls, to Hadley, Chicopee and Agawam, Masschusetts, and all the way to where the river empties into the Long Island Sound. Like Charles Barber, some died and others experienced crippling injuries doing this dangerous job.

David married his first wife, Martha Foxcroft, in 1805, when she was 25 and he was 29. She died in 1821, at age 41. She had never had any children. He then married Wealthy Thomas. There is very little information available on Wealthy Thomas, and what is available on Ancestry.com is inaccurate. Ancestry.com repeatedly lists Wealthy's birthdate as 1780, which is Martha's birthdate. This is impossible for two reasons. In “The History of Windsor County”, by Lewis Aldrich and Frank Holmes, Wealthy Thomas Sumner is said to have died in 1887, which would have made her 107 years old. Also, Wealthy had two children by David, which would have been impossible if she was born in 1880.

I could do a little speculation about Wealthy Thomas. Every source agrees that she came from Hartland. According to the 1830 Windsor census, there was a Thomas family in Hartland, headed by Stephen Thomas, with a female between the ages of 20 and 30. This would have been the right age for Wealthy to have married David in 1839 and to have children, although she would have been quite old when she had her son. I can find no information about Stephen Thomas, and since he seems to have had no sons, this is not surprising.

It is absolutely fair to assume that Wealthy was significantly younger than David when they married, because he was 63 when they married and she had two children by him. I think he married her with the goal in mind of having children. He did wait 18 years to remarry after Martha (Mattie) died. Was that because he finally found another soul mate, or because it took him that long to get over the loss of Mattie? I'm going with the second option, because David and Wealthy's first child was a girl, named Martha Brandon Foxcroft Sumner, the exact name of David's first wife. Interestingly, David seems to be descended from one of the original families at Fort Number 4, and has at least one female ancestor named Martha Brandon Foxcroft, so it seems likely that Martha was a distant relative of David's. In those days it was very common for people to marry second or third cousins.

Wealthy also had a son, David Sumner, Jr. David, Jr was preparing to take over his father's business when he died in 1867 at age 25. The “History of Windsor County” states that this loss killed David, Sr, who died eleven days after his son. Maybe so, but David Sumner didn't have long to live at that point in any case, being 90 years old when he died. The same book also states that Wealthy died in 1887, although maddeningly, it doesn't give her age when she died. She had to have been 35 at the oldest when she had David, (to go back to speculation about Wealthy's age and birth date) which puts her birth date at no earlier than 1807, making her 23 at the time of the 1830 census.

David and Wealthy's daughter Martha, also called Mattie, like David's first wife, inherited the Sumner Mansion and lived there with her husband, Judge Benjamin Steele.